NYX Professional Makeup Suede Matte Lip Liner

NYX Professional Makeup

Form factor: Traditional wooden pencil, Tip color: Vibrant orange/coral, Body color: Dark (black) body consistent with partially visible area, Sharpened tip matches, Product category (lip liner/makeup pencil) matches, High priority retailer (NYX official store)

By The Clique Premium Matte Lip Liner Pencil

Walmart - By The Clique

Form factor: Traditional wooden pencil, Tip color: Orange-red, very close to source, Body color: Black body consistent with partially visible area, Sharpened tip matches, Product category (lip liner pencil) matches, High priority retailer (Walmart)

Lip Pencil Mac

Macy's

Product category: Lip Makeup > Lip Liner Pencil matches 'Lip Makeup', Form factor: Traditional wooden pencil with sharpened tip matches visual in frame, Color: Reddish-brown/nude is a plausible 'orange' shade for lip makeup, Overall design and dimensions are consistent