Milani Understatement Lip Liner

Target

Retractable lip liner type matches exactly, Shimmery/metallic rose gold casing matches exactly, Nude pink shade ('French Rose') matches, Fine tip design matches, Overall form factor and dimensions are consistent, Aligns perfectly with 'Shimmer Casing Nude Pink Lip Liner' description

l'oreal paris L Paris Colour Riche Lip Liner

Walmart

Retractable lip liner type, Shimmery casing, Light pink shade

NYX Retractable Lip Liner

NYX Professional Makeup

Retractable lip liner type, Nude pink shade